War of words looms over Madeleine McCann books

20 March 2011 | Posted by  201 comments


By James Murray

Former Portuguese police chief Goncalo Amaral is set for a new legal battle with Kate and Gerry McCann after writing a second book about their missing daughter Madeleine.

Mr Amaral’s book will be published in Portugal next month shortly before Kate McCann publishes her fundraising book called Madeleine.

It could not come at a worse time for Kate, 42. She is hoping someone who reads her book will come forward with information about the person who took her daughter on May 3, 2007.

The McCanns’ private investigator David Edgar is also preparing to beef up his team in Portugal to react swiftly to any new leads produced by Kate’s book. It goes on sale in Britain on May 12 and a week later in Portugal.

The McCanns have already fought a costly legal battle over Mr Amaral’s first book on the case. Called Maddie: The Truth Of The Lie, it was taken off the shelves for several months before being allowed back on sale.

On Friday the McCanns lost an appeal in Portugal’s Supreme Court to stop his first book from going back on the shelves there.

In the book Mr Amaral put forward the theory that Madeleine had died in apartment 5a of the Ocean Club complex in Praia da Luz on the Algarve. His conclusion angered the McCanns, who insist there is no evidence to suggest Madeleine died there and they still hope she is alive.

Now the stage is set for a fresh legal battle. Mr Amaral’s wife Sofia said: “Goncalo has been working on his book for about six months, spending days and nights assessing all the evidence. He has put in an enormous amount of work. The title has not been decided and a publication date will be sorted out this week.

“At this stage he doesn’t want to say too much, but he will say his investigation was cut short and he will explain what he would have done if he had been allowed to continue. The book is not just about Madeleine. He gives the background to other big cases he was involved with.

“The timing of this new book is just coincidental, nothing was planned. We are not trying to cash in on the fourth anniversary of Madeleine’s disappearance and we do not want a fight over Kate’s book.”

Mr Amaral was a senior investigation officer in the case but was taken off it after criticising British police for an alleged lack of co-operation.

After resigning from the Policia Judiciaria, he has become a successful author in Portugal and regularly appears on television news. He has tried to publish The Truth Of The Lie in Britain but no publisher has accepted it for fear of being sued for libel.

Kate McCann is said to have been warned by her publisher to be careful of what she says about Mr Amaral. However, she does chronicle her frustration with him and her anger over the way he looked at the case.

The Sunday Express can also reveal that Mr Edgar has been making regular trips to Portugal to check out leads in recent months.

A source said: “The investigation is very active. There is a hope that Kate’s book will lead to someone coming forward with the key piece of the jigsaw.”


in: Sunday Express, 20.03.2011

Leonor Cipriano's lawyer to sue the Portuguese State

18 March 2011 | Posted by  18 comments

Évora's Court upheld the PJ Officers convictions

The Appellate Court of Évora did not approve the appeals of the two Judiciary Police officers who were convicted in Leonor Cipriano's trial and decided to maintain the ruling made at the court of first instance, said this Friday Marcos Aragão Coreia, adding that he intends to sue the Portuguese State for violation of Human Rights.

According to Leonor Cipriano's lawyer, the Appellate Court considered "quite sufficient" all the evidence in the first instance to prove the existence of a "serious crime of torture" against Leonor Cipriano.

At trial, held in Faro for several months, the two inspectors of the Judiciary Police, Gonçalo Amaral and António Cardoso, were sentenced to one year and six months and two years and three months respectively, suspended in its execution.

Gonçalo Amaral, the former coordinator of the Criminal Investigation Department in Lagos, was convicted as the author of a crime of false testimony, and António Cardoso, as the author of a crime of forgery of a document.

According to Marcos Aragão Correia, the Court of Appeal of Évora has declared "unfounded" the appeals, including a request by the defendants for "renewal of proof".

from left to right: Joana Isabel Guerreiro Cipriano, Leonor Cipriano convicted for murdering her daughter Joana, Leandro Silva's Mum, Leandro Silva and his sister

The lawyer added that the judges who reviewed the appeals, besides deciding to keep the final ruling made at the first instance, confirmed that Leonor Cipriano "was brutally tortured by various agents of the Portuguese Judiciary Police who remain unidentified."

According to Aragão Correia, the court considered that they "should not worsen" the sentence given to Gonçalo Amaral since he is a "first time offender" and has retired from the police.

Marcos Aragão Correia announced that in consequence of this decision, Leonor Cipriano will lodge a formal complaint against the Portuguese government to the United Nations for "gross violation of the most basic human rights".

According to the lawyer, it will be asked the condemnation and expulsion of Portugal from the Human Rights Commission of the United Nations.

in Correio da Manhã 18.03.2011

Related (in no particular order)

Leonor Cipriano’s lawyer confesses to lying to obtain a confession

More Metodo 3 "witnesses" : Lawyer Claims Madeleine Raped, Murdered and Dumped

Leonor Cipriano’s lawyer confesses to having used “creepy” method

Family refuses to accept Leonor Cipriano back

Maddie and Joana: Esotericism, plot, psychotic disturbance or a mere case of fooling the public?

Detectives Hired by the McCanns want to Frame Gonçalo Amaral

Supreme Court refuses to review Joana case sentence

Marcos Aragão Correia accused of defaming Gonçalo Amaral

Marcos Aragão Correia Disrupted Gonçalo Amaral's Birthday Party

Marcos Aragão Correia launches ‘support site’ for Leonor, Leandro, Kate and Gerry

Marcos Aragão Correia wants 500 thousand €uros from Gonçalo Amaral

Addendum to the Criminal Process for Defamation Against Marcos Aragão Correia

etc..


Supreme Court turns down McCanns' request



by Margarida Davim

Kate and Gerry McCann wanted the Supreme Court of Justice to nullify a decision by the Appeals Court that allowed for the book by Gonçalo Amaral, ‘The Truth of the Lie’, to be distributed. Nonetheless, the judges have refused the request.

Former Polícia Judiciária inspector Gonçalo Amaral will again be able to sell the book about the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, ‘The Truth of the Lie’, which was taken off shelves after an injunction that was filed by the parents of the little English girl that disappeared in Praia da Luz was accepted by a lower court.

The Supreme Court judges refused the request for an “exceptional review” of the Appeals Court’s decision, which overturned the injunction that had been filed by Kate and Gerry McCann.

The counsellors’ decision may be appealed to the Constitutional Court, but that will have no suspensive effect, which means that Kate and Gerry McCann will have to return every copy of Amaral’s book that they possess.

If they do not comply, they may even incur in a crime of disobedience.

Contacted by Sol, the McCanns’ lawyer, Isabel Duarte, refused to comment on this judicial decision, because she hadn’t been notified yet.

in: Sol, 18.03.2011

Read as well:

Lisbon Appeals Court Decision on the McCann Couple Injunction
24 Oct 2010 - This is the English translation of the full text of the Appellate Court decision that recently overturned the ban on Dr. Gonçalo Amaral's book, “Maddie - A Verdade da Mentira”, which has been commonly known to English-speaking people as “Maddie - The Truth of The Lie”.

McCanns appeal to the Supreme Court to forbid Gonçalo Amaral’s book
10 Nov 2010 - The McCann couple has appealed to the Supreme Court of Justice against the Appellate Court’s decision to overturn the ban on the sales of Gonçalo Amaral’s book “Maddie – The Truth of the Lie”, the lawyer that represents the parents of the child that went missing in the Algarve said today.

The McCanns' Injunction: Quotes by the Defence Lawyers
24 Feb 2010 - The following quotes come from notes taken in loco [on spot] at the 7th Civil Court, at Palace of Justice in Lisbon, on the day when the closing arguments were presented by the defence lawyers of the four entities targeted in this case and by the McCanns layer.

The Temporary Injunction: Granted on September 9, 2009
4 Feb 2010 - This is a translation of the text of the Civil Court ruling that granted the temporary injunction on Gonçalo Amaral’s book, ‘Maddie – The Truth of the Lie’, and the corresponding DVD. It was issued on the 9th of September, 2009. (...) It should also be recalled that this injunction was granted exclusively based on the evidence that was provided by the Applicants. The Defendants were only allowed to oppose the injunction after it had been granted.

Gonçalo Amaral in Court: Witnesses defend that book results from the Investigation
13 Jan 2010 - The defense witnesses sustained this Tuesday, at the trial about the prohibition of the book "Maddie - The Truth of the Lie" that the thesis of the former PJ Inspector Gonçalo Amaral regarding the McCann couple involvement in their daughter's disappearence resulted from the police investigation.

Censure back in Portugal: Court Bans Gonçalo Amaral Book & Film
9 Sep 2009 - The civil court of Lisbon accepted a restraining injunction by Gerry and Kate McCann and ordered to take from the market the book "A Verdade da Mentira", written by Gonçalo Amaral, which defends the thesis that the parents are involved in the Homicide and disappearance of Madeleine McCann.



Cliff concealed baby's bones

10 March 2011 | Posted by  62 comments


by Paulo Marcelino

The PJ believes that the bones that were discovered at a cliff near Beliche beach, in Sagres, belong to Alexandra, the 18-month-old baby that was taken by her father after he murdered the child’s mother at Canavial beach, in Lagos, on the 10th of July last year.

The skull and a femur were located on a cliff ledge, 15 metres away from the water and at a distance of 20 metres from the rock’s top. They were discovered on Tuesday evening, at around 11 p.m., by two fishermen who were descending a narrow path. Yesterday morning, vertebrae, ribs, a part of another femur and the lower jawbone were found, approximately 10 metres away from the path.

The dimension of the bones and the residues of black, curly hair point towards the baby’s mortal remains. The bones have been taken to the Forensic Medicine Cabinet of Portimão, where the body of Georgina Zito remains unclaimed. An autopsy and a DNA test will be performed in order to confirm the identity.

Gunnar murdered Georgina four days after the couple arrived in Lagos. He simulated a drowning at Canavial beach and fled with the little girl. The baby’s remains were now found 35 kilometres away, in Sagres. The man returned to Munich on the 15th of July and was detained, after which he opposed extradition to Portugal.

in: Correio da Manhã, 10.03.2011


Portimão: PJ investigates human remains

9 March 2011 | Posted by  8 comments


The Polícia Judiciária (PJ) of Portimão is investigating the origin of human remains that were found on Tuesday night, at a beach slope in the area of Praia do Beliche, in Sagres.

According to the commander of the Portimão and Lagos Port, the Maritime Police was alerted at around 11 p.m. on Tuesday to "the presence of bones that could belong to a person", deposited halfway at a beach slope near Praia do Beliche, in Sagres, in the municipality of Vila do Bispo.

Commander Cruz Martins added that "the bones vere visible and an initial analysis has indicated that they belong to a person", with the case being handed over to the Public Ministry and the PJ for further investigation.

A source at the PJ has said that the "human bones appear to be those of a very young person", but only after the exams and analysis that will be performed at the Institute for Forensic Medicine, in Lisbon, "will it be possible to determine their origin".

The police authorities do not set aside the possibility that the human remains belong to a 21-month-old child that disappeared in July 2010, whose mother was drowned at a beach in Lagos.

The suspect of the mother's death and of having made the child, who was both their daughter, disappear during the holidays that they were spending in Lagos, is a 43-year-old German citizen who is presently detained in Germany, following an arrest warrant that was issued by the Portuguese authorities.


in: Correio da Manhã, 09.03.2011


Madeleine McCann - Portuguese Truck Driver Quizzed

6 March 2011 | Posted by  53 comments


By James Murray

Investigators working for Kate and Gerry McCann are trying to discover if a Portuguese lorry driver facing prosecution for child kidnapping is linked to the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.

They are looking into whether the 34-year-old accused of kidnapping an 11-year-old Portuguese boy was in Praia da Luz, on the Algarve, when Madeleine vanished nearly four years ago.

Rui Pedro Teixeira Mendonca vanished from his home town of Lousado, near Porto in the north of the country, in March 1998. Detectives believe he was kidnapped while walking home from school and taken to a prostitute who was paid to have sex with him.

Shortly after he was snatched there was also an unconfirmed sighting of the boy at Disneyland in Paris with a middle-aged man, suggesting he could have been moved around Europe by a paedophile gang.

In 2001 his mother was flown to Switzerland to see if a child sex video seized in that country contained footage of her son.

A breakthrough in the case was made when the prostitute allegedly confessed that she had been with the boy. She confirmed the suspect was seen with Rui Pedro on the day he vanished.

Former British detectives working as private investigators for Kate and Gerry McCann will now try to discover the movements of the suspect over the past 13 years. The Sunday Express knows the identity of the man, but cannot name him for legal reasons. It is understood he travelled extensively around Portugal.

Dave Edgar, the McCann’s main investigator, is keen to know if he has ever visited the Algarve, and in particular the resort from where Madeleine was kidnapped in May, 2007.

The man lived in Lousada but moved away after the disappearance of Rui Pedro and is believed to be married with a small child.

Detectives have passed a file on the case to a court for prosecution on child kidnapping. It is expected the suspect will be arrested and questioned in the coming weeks. In the past Rui Pedro’s mother Filomena has sent several messages of support to Kate and Gerry McCann. Pictures of both missing children appear on a missing persons’ website in Portugal.

After Madeleine disappeared, Filomena said: “When I saw the news about the disappearance of the English girl I was terrified. I immediately thought of my son, even though the cases are different, and I thought of Madeleine’s parents, the anguish they are suffering.”

Three years ago the suspect, who admits being with the boy on the day he disappeared, said: “As far as Rui Pedro is concerned, the thing I want most in the world is that he appears.

“I never denied being with him. But I never saw him again after we parted company that day and I haven’t a clue what happened to him.”

in: Sunday Express, March 6, 2011

Madeleine McCann flat to be let again

The holiday flat from which Madeleine McCann vanished is being put up for rental in the spring

By Sunday Express reporter

THE holiday flat from which Madeleine McCann vanished is being put up for rental in the spring after attempts to sell it failed, writes James Murray.

The disappearance of the three-year-old on May 3, 2007, made Apartment 5a of the Ocean Club in Praia de Luz on the Algarve notorious and over the past three summers it has been empty.

A year later, the owner, Ruth McCann of Liverpool, who is not related to Madeleine’s parents Kate and Gerry, tried to sell the property. The asking price was about £225,000 but she had no luck.

A source said: “It has been incredibly difficult for Ruth. She has money tied up in the property and needs to get it back.

“It was on the market for quite a time but there was never any real interest.

“Now it is hoped that people can finally move on and see the place as just a lovely apartment.

“The hope is that when some people rent it and the locals see that, then gradually people will stop associating the property with Madeleine.”

However, memories will be stirred up again on May 12 when Kate McCann publishes her book, Madeleine. She will undertake a round of interviews in Europe and America to try to keep the case in the public eye and to raise funds to continue the hunt for her lost daughter.

in : Sunday Express , March 6, 2011

Extra weekend spin

Secret video of Maddie suspect
News of the World
MADELEINE McCann suspect Raymond Hewlett said his wife would "go mental" if she was asked about the missing girl in a dramatic video recorded before his ...



Last Weekend Spin (Thanks to Nige at the McCann Files)

Kate plea to perv's widow
News of the World (paper edition)

Mum to mum ... please tell

EXCLUSIVE By Matthew Drake
Sunday 27 Feb 2011

HEARTBROKEN Kate McCann is pleading with the widow of a dead paedophile to break her silence in the hunt for snatched daughter Madeleine.

But Mariana Schmuecker – herself a mother of six -has snubbed FOUR requests to reveal secrets about her husband, convicted child rapist Raymond Hewlett.

Detectives believe what she knows could hold the vital key to their investigation.

When the News of the World confronted her the callous German just snarled: "Clear off! I'm sick to death of hearing about Maddie McCann!".

Flawed

Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry desperately want Mariana to shed light on Hewlett's links with child-sex perverts in Portugal’s Algarve, where three-year-old Maddie vanished in May 2007.

Ex-fairground worker Hewlett bore a striking resemblence to the straggly-haired man seen lurking near the McCanns' holiday apartment.

His previous conviction included the rape of a 12-year-old girl he lured into his car then drugged with paint stripper. And he was bragged how gipsies had offered him "good money" for his own blonde-haired daughter aged two.

But Mariana, who suddenly shipped off to Morocco with Hewlett just three weeks after Maddie's disappearance, has stayed tight- lipped – even about her partner's flawed alibi.

Hewlett claimed that on the Thursday Madeleine (right) was abducted he was with his family at a market up the coast in Fuzets. But that market is only held on Saturdays. A source close to the McCanns told us: "Through detectives Kate has begged Mariana to speak out and hopes she will do the right thing. As a mother herself you'd think she'd want to help."

Mariana lives with her kids in the German city of Aachen, in the same flat she shared with Hewlett before he died two years ago of throat cancer at 64.

A source close to the investigation said: "Our detectives are pretty certain Mariana knows a lot about Hewlett's background and activities. That would open up doors to paedophile networks in the Algarve.

"We were never able to rule Hewlett out as a suspect. He'd have had useful information and we're convinced Mariana is more than able to fill in the gaps. But she just tells us to go away or puts the phone down."

"We want to know WHO she knows, and WHAT she's heard about possible routes to spirit a child out of the country."

"She and Hewlett left Portugal at a rate of knots because he feared being associated with Madeleine's disappearance."

"We wanted to know about the six children Mariana and Hewlett had because none of them had any official birth documents. And there was a seventh child who died in mysterious circumstances."

"They never explained how they could move from country to country with the children despite having no passports."

And also:

New Maddie hope

By Jonathan Corke
27th February 2011

MADELEINE McCann's parents hope a major police breakthrough against human trafficking in Portugal's Algarve might lead them to their missing daughter.

We can reveal how, in a huge bust earlier this month, 12 men were arrested on suspicion of trafficking women and children and forcing them into the sex trade.

And it is hoped they could have vital information on Madeleine's case and may even know who took her from the resort of Praia da Luz in May 2007.

Last night Madeleine's parents, doctors Kate and Gerry McCann, both 42, were anxiously waiting to hear of any new lines of inquiry.

Spokesman Clarence Mitchell said: "Clearly any information that the Portuguese authorities gather from this operation that is relevant to Madeleine would be of crucial importance.

"Obviously, Kate and Gerry will want to hear from the relevant authorities should anything of significance develop."

The raid, codenamed Operation Roadbook, saw immigration officials from Portugal's SEF border security agency and police join forces to smash the network.

According to detectives, 30 young women, including several under-age girls, were rescued as eight properties and 11 cars were raided across the Algarve and Aveiro, in the north of Portugal.

The SEF said they believe the ring to be responsible for the sexual exploitation of "many" young women in the Algarve.

In a statement they said: "The network used very violent physical and psychological coercion to force dozens of young women into prostitution.

"Some of the women were found to be underage while others had been the victims of the forced administration of narcotics."

According to the SEF, the gang constantly moved the girls to different locations, both in Portugal and outside the country, where they would be sold and traded.

"The movement of the prostitutes between different networks hindered the police and judicial authorities in being able to conduct a criminal investigation.

"But authorities in Spain, Italy, the UK and Germany co-operated with us with the assistance of Europol in this case."

A police source said missing persons cases in the Algarve were being looked at as a result of the sting.

Madeleine, from Rothley, Leics, was just three when she vanished from the holiday resort of Praia da Luz in the Algarve nearly four years ago.

Investigators trying to track down the missing girl have long suspected her to be the victim of a professional human trafficking network.

A source said: "Even if these men were not involved they may have information about who was and the channels used."

The 12 men, who are all EU citizens, are being held in custody with court hearings taking place in the main Algarve tourist city of Albufeira.

Note - the original article published on February 9, 2011 at Serviço de Estrangeiros e Fronteiras (SEF) site makes no mention of Madeleine McCann.