Scotland Yard searches for clues about Madeleine McCann in Barcelona

14 December 2011 | Posted by  121 comments

New Searches in the case of the missing child
Agents from the Scotland Yard and from the Spanish National Police carry boxes with documents given by the detectives agency, yesterday in Barcelona

by Makya Navarro (Madrid)

Police from the Scotland Yard search for clues about the mysterious disappearance of the little girl, Madeleine McCann, which occurred in May 3, 2007 at the Portuguese Algarve, where she was on holidays with her parents. The little girl disappeared a few days before her fourth birthday.

The British agents collected yesterday from the investigative agency Método 3 various boxes with copies of all the documentation that this private detectives accumulated during the six months they have worked for the parents of the girl. The London Metropolitan police reopened last May the review by order of the prime minister, David Cameron, and due to the request made by the parents.

Since then, Scotland Yard, reviews the investigations that were carried out, accordingly. They also have available a copy of the Portuguese police investigations, that archived the case in July of 2008 due to lack of evidence. Scotland Yard has allocated thirty people to this new investigation.

In the night of her disappearance, Madeleine slept in a bungalow in Praia da Luz with her two siblings whilst her parents dined at the near by bar.

Neither the police investigation, nor the private searches supported by the parents, nor the noisy media circus created around the dozens of alleged clues of the most varied kind have been able to explain what happened.

in El Periódico de Cataluña, 14 December 2011
At the time of this post this is the only online article in Spanish that mentions Scotland Yard and the Spanish detective agency Método 3 (PDF in Spanish here)

The Spin from the UK media

Maddy police 'following eight major new leads'
by Tom Worden in Barcelona and Justin Davenport

Scotland Yard detectives searching for Madeleine McCann are examining up to eight "very important" new leads after meeting Spanish private investigators, it was claimed today.

Four officers yesterday visited the Barcelona HQ of Metodo 3, the agency employed to look for her by Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry for six months after she vanished.

The British officers, from a 30-strong Met team reviewing the case, took away 30 boxes of documents compiled by the private detectives.

The agency's director, Francisco Marco, said there were "six, seven or eight very important leads" within the files which he claimed could help police to solve the case.

Madeleine, of Rothley in Leicestershire, disappeared from her parents' holiday apartment in Praia da Luz on the Algarve in Portugal in May 2007. She was days short of her fourth birthday.

It is the second visit by British officers, who were in Barcelona last month. Mr Marco said on Spanish TV today: "We have provided them with all the documents and information we have collated worldwide about Madeleine's disappearance so they can continue the investigations we carried out in Spain, Morocco and the rest of the world.

"I think there are six, seven or eight very important leads in there."

He claimed Portuguese police ignored the leads for political reasons, and that when his investigators visited Portugal, "we were never allowed to do a proper job. The English police are now continuing with an investigation which should never have been closed".

Asked if he believed Madeleine is still alive, Mr Marco said: "When we were investigating we were always trying to find a living child. Hopefully for the parents she will be found alive."

Madeleine's parents, who have younger twins, a boy and a girl, hired Metodo 3 to find Madeleine four months after she vanished, for a reported £50,000 a month.

The agency, which it was claimed had 40 staff working on the case, sent a team to Morocco to chase up leads that she might have been smuggled out of Portugal.

Today Mr Marco said he still believed that was "very possibly" what happened to her but he refused to give more details on the leads.

in The Evening Standard, 14 December 2011

Update

Private detective says up to eight strong leads in Madeleine McCann's disappearance were ignored by Portuguese police

From the same churnalist Tom Worden

30 boxes of files handed over to Scotland Yard
Agency followed leads in Spain and Morocco
Portuguese police criticised for closing case



Scotland Yard detectives searching for Madeleine McCann are examining up to eight 'very important' new leads after meeting private investigators in Spain, it emerged today.

On Tuesday four detectives visited the Barcelona headquarters of Metodo 3 - a Spanish agency that spent six months working for Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry.

The British officers - from a 30-strong Metropolitan Police team carrying out a review of the case - took away around 30 boxes of documents compiled by the private investigators.

Afterwards the agency's director, Francisco Marco, said there were 'six, seven or eight very important leads' within the files that could help police locate Madeleine.

Mr Marco also criticised Portuguese police for failing to follow up those leads, and for shelving the Madeleine investigation.



He was a guest on the Spanish TV show The Ana Rosa Programme this morning, and said: 'We have provided [Scotland Yard] with all the documents and information we have collated worldwide about Madeleine's disappearance so they can continue the investigations we carried out in Spain, Morocco and the rest of the world.

'I think there are six, seven or eight very important leads in there.

'They were passed at the time to Portuguese police who ignored them because it was a very politicised issue and they didn't want to look into anything that didn't come from their own sources... because of Portuguese chauvinism in this case, because they didn't want the English [police] or private detectives to discover more than they did.

'Every time anyone from Metodo 3 went to Portugal they were continually followed and monitored to see what they were doing.

'We were never allowed to do a proper job. Scotland Yard can now continue with all the work we did outside of Portugal and inside Portugal as well.

'The English police are now continuing with an investigation which should never have been closed.'

Asked if he believed Madeleine was still alive, Mr Marco said: 'When we were investigating we were always trying to find a living child.

'I'm not going to answer your question because I don't want to offend the parents.

'Hopefully for the parents she will be found alive. I am a father, and to lose a child and not know where he or she is is the worst thing in the world.'

Today Barcelona-based newspaper El Periodico de Catalunya published photographs of the Scotland Yard detectives, wearing suits, leaving the offices of Metodo 3, in the plush Eixample district of the city.

Metodo 3 were hired by the McCanns to look for their daughter in September 2007 - four months after Madeleine, days short of her fourth birthday, went missing during a family holiday in Praia da Luz, on the Algarve.

They were reportedly paid £50,000 a month to search for Madeleine and sent a team to Morocco to chase up leads that she might have been smuggled out of Portugal to north Africa.

Mr Marco was in daily contact with doctors Kate and Gerry, from Rothley, Leicestershire, and claimed he had 40 staff working on the case.

In December 2007 he was criticised after claiming in a newspaper interview that he knew who had abducted Madeleine and would have her home for Christmas.

Metodo 3 continued to work part-time on the search for Madeleine after their six-month contract - funded by the McCanns' backer Brian Kennedy and the Find Madeleine Fund - expired.

Today Mr Marco said he still believed it was 'very possible' Madeleine had been smuggled out of Portugal to Morocco. He refused to go into further detail about the nature of the fresh leads.

Also included in the files taken by Scotland Yard are investigations the agency carried out into Raymond Hewlett, a convicted British paedophile who was in Portugal when Madeleine went missing and left for Morocco three weeks later.

Hewlett, an ex-soldier and convicted child rapist, died of throat cancer aged 64 in Germany last year having refused to talk to detectives about Madeleine's disappearance.

Prime Minister David Cameron asked the Met to examine all the evidence connected to the Madeleine case in July.

Scotland Yard detectives travelled to Spain last month to meet with officers from the National Police and Civil Guard force.

They were also reportedly interested in chasing up a suspicious incident in Barcelona three days after Madeleine went missing.

A well-dressed woman with an Australian or New Zealand accent, described as looking like Victoria Beckham, is said to have approached a British tourist in the city's port area and asked him: 'Are you here to deliver my new daughter?'

in Daily Mail, 14 December 2011 (at 14:37)

«A Scotland Yard spokesman refused to confirm the meeting took place.

“We will not be providing a running commentary,” he added.

Family spokesman Clarence Mitchell added: “Kate and Gerry will simply not be commenting whilst the Metropolitan Police review of Madeleine’s case is under way.

“They remain pleased that the Met team is continuing its work and that progress is being made.”»

in The Mirror, Irish Examiner, etc

Related to Método 3 (in no particular order)

Francisco Marco:We know who took Madeleine - and she'll be home by Christmas'

Madeleine McCann and Metodo 3: Private eyes, public lies

More Metodo 3 "witnesses" : Lawyer Claims Madeleine Raped, Murdered and Dumped

Madeleine: Pictured in handcuffs, the McCann detective once held over phone tapping

McCann Spin: Gypsy link to Maddie

Is Maddie Still Alive?

News Recap: Amaral, McCanns, Halligen and a FOIA request

Metodo 3: The Spanish CIA?

Former McCann detectives Metodo3 Investigated by Judge

Brian Kennedy No Longer Paying for the Maddie Campaign

Agents without abduction leads - Correio da Manhã

McCann Hired More Private Investigators

McCanns New Detectives Face Criticism

McCanns: Metodo 3 Back in Action?!

Metodo 3: Francisco Marco in Court

El Mundo Journalist Arrested for Alleged connections to Drug Traffickers

McCanns and Metodo 3: The Spanish Connection?

Metodo 3 and Team Mccann U-Turn

McCanns are 'wasting fund cash on Madeleine hunt in Morocco'

Maddie and Joana: Crossing Paths - SIC In-Depth Report

Leonor’s lawyer received money from the McCanns - 24Horas

Maddie and Joana: Esotericism, plot, psychotic disturbance or a mere case of fooling the public?

One lawyer, three visions and a deafening silence

Cipriano/McCann Case: Aragao Denies He is Being Paid Just to Frame Gonçalo Amaral

Detectives Hired by the McCanns want to Frame Gonçalo Amaral

McCanns' Mission Impossible: Scaling Down the Search that Never Was or Honey, I Shrunk the Search!

McCanns want evidence - 24Horas


McCann Spin: Gypsy link to Maddie

13 December 2011 | Posted by  20 comments

Clarence Mitchell spinning the "Gypsies" who dun it, January 2008

BRITISH detectives are to return to Spain to investigate a possible gypsy link in the disappearance of Maddie McCann.

A team from Scotland Yard have already spent three days looking into claims that the youngster was smuggled into Spain and taken to Barcelona.

They met with both Spain’s UDYCO organised crime unit and detective Dave Edgar, who has spent years investigating the Spanish claims.

 Dave Edgar  & Clarence Mitchell promoting a "Victoria Beckham" look-a-like suspect seen in Barcelona, August 2009

Now they are reported to be returning to investigate the theory that she was snatched by a child kidnap gang run by gypsies.

Portuguese police have already investigated a report by holidaymaker Andre van Wyk that he had seen a girl resembling Madeleine being taken in a cart to a gypsy camp near Portimao, about 16kms from where Maddie disappeared.

Days later a British holidaymaker Jean Godwin saw a girl – ’100 per cent Madeleine’ – being dragged around by ‘gypsy women’ 35kms away.

Her information was followed up by both detective Edgar working for the McCann’s and Portuguese police, but nothing was ever conclusive.

The latest development is part of an on-going ‘investigative review’ into the girl’s disappearance in Portugal in 2007, ordered by Prime Minister David Cameron last year.

Last week, the McCann’s spokesman Clarence Mitchell said: “Kate and Gerry welcome the on-going work by the Metropolitan Police and they are pleased that the investigative review is making progress.”

in The Olive press, December 13, 2011

Related:

Francisco Marco: We know who took Madeleine - and she'll be home by Christmas', Daily Mail, December 12, 2007

More Metodo 3 "witnesses" : Lawyer Claims Madeleine Raped, Murdered and Dumped, this blog, January 13, 2008

Madeleine detectives fly to Spain on trail of paedophile gang, Daily Mail, January 15, 2008

Madeleine McCann and Metodo 3: Private eyes, public lies, Murdoch's The Times, 9 February 2008

Analysis of Kate and Gerry's involvement in disappearince (sic) of daughter Maddie one year on, Murdoch's Sun, April 2008

Detectives Hired by the McCanns want to Frame Gonçalo Amaral, this blog, February 13, 2009

New Sketch Of 'Creepy Madeleine Suspect', this blog, January 19, 2010

Madeleine 'suspect' images issued, BBC, January 20, 2010

Madeleine McCann: Fat Men, Gypsies And Pictures Of Kiwi Paedos, Anorak, March 3, 2010

Madeleine 'held in remote shack', Express, March 4, 2010

'I'm convinced the little girl I saw was Madeleine McCann': The riddle of Maddie and 'the fat gipsy women', Daily Mail, March 10, 2010

Fat gypsies, white vans and pink pyjamas, this blog on an article by the Sun, May 25, 2010

Murdoch's Scum gets even more scummiest: Dead Paedophile's Ghost “knew” who took Maddie, this blog on an article by the Sun/News of the World, September 1, 2010

Maddie ‘seen with suspect’ in Dubai, Murdoch's Sun, January 20, 2011

Madeleine McCann: Yard Cops Fly To Spain, Murdoch's Sky News, December 5, 2011

Detectives travel to Barcelona in hunt for Madeleine McCann 'to probe reports she was smuggled to Spain, Daily Mail, December 6, 2011

British Police Fly to Spain to Re-Examine Case of Missing Madeleine McCann, Murdoch's Fox news, December 10, 2011

A Chronological Record of Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Limited Company

12 December 2011 | Posted by  16 comments

The McCann couple on the day that should have been Madeleine's fourth birthday, just 9 days after the child's disappearance, after a mass for their daughter in Praia da Luz Church on May 12, 2007

Certificate of Incorporation of Private Limited Company - Madeleine's Fund: leaving no Stone unturned Limited, 15 May 2007

Terminating appointment as director or secretary - Bates Wells & Braithwaite as directors of the fund, signed by John McCann, 16 May 2007

Find Madeleine fund launched - The Sun, 16 May 2007 (article no longer exists online)
Extract:
«Ways to donate

OVER the counter in branches of NatWest and the Royal Bank of
Scotland.

By sending a cheque, made payable to ‘Madeleine’s Fund: Leaving No
Stone Unturned’, to: Madeleine’s Fund, c/o The International Family Law
Group, 26 Southampton Street, Covent Garden, WC2E 7RS.

By internet bank transfer to “Madeleine’s Fund: Leaving No Stone
Unturned”, Sort Code 60 40 05, Account Number 32130058.
All donations will be processed free of charge.

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Site, 19 May 2007 (cached at wayback machine)
The balance on the account current stands at £73,505.58.
This includes £50,000 donated by Portsmouth football club.
Funds taken over the counters of NatWest & RBS, along with the donations made by cheque, have not yet hit the account.
Further updates will be provided on Monday 21st May 2007

Text “MADDIE” to 60999 and £1 will be taken from your phone for the Madeleine Fund. (Standard network charges may apply)

Fund Details
The family of Madeleine McCann are to-day launching the Madeleine’s Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned appeal. The funds will be used to help find Madeleine McCann, support her family and bring her abductors to justice. Any surplus funds will be used to help families and missing children in United Kingdom, Portugal and elsewhere in similar circumstances.

From this morning, Thursday May 17th:
members of the public will be able to make donations to 'Madeleine's Fund : Leaving No Stone Unturned Limited' over-the-counter in any branch of NatWest and The Royal Bank of Scotland.

From now:
Postal Donations can be made with cheques payable to 'Madeleine's Fund : Leaving No Stone Unturned'. Cheques should be posted to the following address:

‘Madeleine’s Fund’
c/o The International Family Law Group
26 Southampton Street
Covent Garden
London
WC2E 7RS

Internet donations can be made into the following account:
'Madeleine's Fund : Leaving No Stone Unturned'
Branch
Natwest
PO BOX 113
Cavell House
2A Charing Cross Road
London
WC2H ONN
Sort Code 60 40 05.
Account Number 32130058

Internet banking donations from abroad
IBAN : GB63 NWBK 6040 0532 1300 58
or
IBAN : GB63NWBK60400532130058
Sort Code : 60 – 40 – 05
Account number : 32130058
Iban bic : NWBKGB2L
All donations will be processed free of charge.

Funds will be paid to Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Limited: Company Registration Number - 6248215
3. The objects of the Foundation are:
3.1.1 To secure the safe return to her family of Madeleine McCann who was abducted in Praia da Luz, Portugal on Thursday 3rd May 2007;
3.1.2 To procure that Madeleine’s abduction is thoroughly investigated and that her abductors, as well as those who played or play any part in assisting them, are identified and brought to justice; and
3.1.3 To provide support, including financial assistance, to Madeleine’s family.
3.2 If the above objects are fulfilled then the objects of the Foundation shall be to pursue such purposes in similar cases arising in the United Kingdom, Portugal or elsewhere.

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Site, 21 May 2007, £115,856.92 Paypal option to donate is introduced

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Site, 1 June 2007, £581,813.01

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Site, 8 June 2007, £713,927.81

 Gerry McCann, Kate McCann and Brian Ashton pose holding a Find Madeleine T-shirt during the England training session at Browns Sports Complex on July 4, 2007 in Vilamoura, Portugal

McCanns' pledge on fund - BBC East Midlands, 12 September 2007 (after the McCanns were constituted as arguidos i.e. official criminal suspects)

Kate and Gerry McCann have said that money raised to help find Madeleine will not be used to clear their names.

Gerry's Blogs (Days 121-181) Sep/Oct 2007
«Statement by the Board of Madeleine’s Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Limited
12 September 2007
The Fund would like to thank everyone for their kindness, support and generosity.
Madeleine’s Fund was set up to:
Find Madeleine; Support the Family; and Bring the abductor or abductors to justice and subject to that to help other missing children. With the sudden dramatic and unexpected turn of events at the weekend the directors had to consider whether legal defence costs could be paid for by the Fund.
The Board has taken advice from Bates Wells & Braithwaite London LLP and Christopher McCall QC. The Board has been advised that payment of Gerry and Kate’s legal defence costs would be legally permissible subject to conditions about repayment in the event of a guilty conviction.

The directors of the Fund discussed this today. The two family directors, Brian Kennedy and John McCann withdrew from the meeting when the decision was made. Esther Mcvey chaired the meeting.

The Fund directors realise that there is not only a legal answer and recognise the spirit which underlies the generous donations to Madeleine’s Fund, which it is the directors’ responsibility to steer.

For this reason the Fund directors have decided not to pay for Gerry and Kate’s legal defence costs. We stress that Gerry and Kate have not asked for these costs to be paid. However, people have already called in offering their financial support. Any such fund to pay legal defence costs would have to be separately set up and administered.

At the heart of this campaign and Fund is a little girl confused, lonely and in need of her parents. This Fund’s money will be focused on finding that little girl and leaving no stone unturned.»

Esther McVey: Madeleine's fund won't be used for legal fees, 18 September 2007
Extract:
«Kate and Gerry, 39 - also parents of two-year-old twins Sean and Amelie, both fiercely deny any involvement in the long-running mystery and believe they are being set up to cover up a bungled police inquiry.

This week, prospective MP Esther McVey, one of the six trustees of Madeleine's fund, met with lawyers to examine the legality of breaking into the £1m worth of public donations.

She said that the fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned was set up to find Madeleine, support the family, bring the abductor(s) to justice and subject to that, help other missing children.

But numerous angry postings from people who claim to have given donations have appeared on the internet asking if they are entitled to their money back if Madeleine's parents are prosecuted.

"Fund directors have decided not to pay for Kate and Gerry's legal defence costs," said Esther. "We stress that the family has not asked for these costs to be paid, however, people have already called in offering their financial support.

"Any such fund would have to be separately set up and administered." (....)»

Madeleine's Fund: leaving no Stone unturned Limited (Limited by guarantee) Report and Financial Statements for the period ended 31 March 2008

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving no Stone Unturned Limited Full Report, 23 January 2009

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving no Stone Unturned Limited (Limited by guarantee) Report and Financial Statements for the period ended 31 March 2009
The Chairman presents his statement for the year.
On 3rd May 2007, Madeleine McCann was abducted in Praia da Luz, Portugal. The events of that day touched the heart of many, in countries around the world. Donations started to flood in. In response to this, Madeleine's Fund was established.
The aims of the Fund are to help find Madeleine, to support her family and to bring her abductors to justice. Any surplus funds will be used to help families and missing children in similar circumstances in the United Kingdom, Portugal and elsewhere. The Fund has 7 directors. We have continued to concentrate on ensuring that Madeleine is not forgotten and that the search for her continues.

We have:
• provided finance for a team of investigators to lead a private search for Madeleine
• financed the translation of the full set of files released by the Portuguese police, enabling our team of investigators to follow up all potential leads
• paid for legal representation for Kate, Gerry, Sean and Amelie in Portugal, enabling them obtain an injunction banning Mr Amoral (sic) from repeating his fabricated claims about Madeleine's abduction
• funded an awareness-raising campaign to ensure that Madeleine is not forgotten, the key part of which is our website
• provided some administrative support to Madeleine's family in maintaining the impetus of the investigation

Last year [referred to the public apology made to Madeleine's parents, Kate and Gerry, by the Express Group following months of inaccurate speculation and accusations in the media. Other newspapers followed suit with accompanying donations to Madeleine's Fund. In addition, an apology was made to the friends of Gerry and Kate who were in Praia da Luz at the time of Madeleine's abduction. Rather than accepting libel damages, the friends requested that a donation was made to the fund. This has enabled us to continue our search for Madeleine. On behalf of the directors of Madeleine's Fund, I thank Kate, Gerry and their friends for continuing to forego any personal financial recompense to ensure that the search for Madeleine continues.

Following the end of the financial year we were delighted to hear that Madeleine's parents, brother and sister had been successful in obtaining an injunction banning sales of Mr Amoral's (sic) book and banning him from repeating his claims.
These fabrications had hindered the search for Madeleine and were a barrier to potentially valuable information being passed on to the police. Our team of investigators continue to diligently review police files, witness statements and follow up every potential lead in the search for Madeleine.

Although the majority of donation income for the year arose from family and friends donating libel damages, we have a number of loyal donors continuing their support. For this we are grateful. As expected, income in the new financial year is lower than last year and we continue to review all our expenses to ensure value for money. The directors regularly discuss the strategy for the Fund to ensure that finances are available to achieve our main objective, finding Madeleine.

The Board of Directors would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has supported the search for Madeleine. The level of financial support, the amount of time given up and the numerous messages of support sent to Madeleine's family have been overwhelming. All messages of support sent to the Fund are passed to Gerry and Kate, and appreciated by them. We will continue to ensure that Madeleine is not forgotten and will leave no stone unturned in our search for her.

John McCann
Chairman

Annual Return - Details of Officers of the Company, 15 May 2009

Change of Director's Details Kate McCann, 1 October 2009

Change of Director's details Peter Hubner, 1 October 2009

Change of Director's details Brian Kennedy, 1 October 2009

Change of director's details Douglas Skehan, 1 October 2009

Change of director's details John McCann, 1 October 2009

Change of particulars for Corporate Secretary (BWB Secretarial Limited - Bates Wells & Braithwaite, London, UK), 1 October 2009

Madeleine's Fund Leaving No Stone Unturned Limited Full Report, 27 January 2010
Screenshot from Companycheck.co.uk

Madeleine's Fund: Leaving no Stone Unturned Limited (Limited by guarantee) Report and Financial Statements for the period ended 31 March 2010

Annual Return - Details of Officers of the Company 15 May 2010

John McCann Resignation from Madeleine's Fund: Leaving no Stone Unturned Limited, 23 July 2010

Douglas Skehan Resignation from Madeleine's Fund: Leaving no Stone Unturned Limited, 24 August 2010

Credit Report & Accounts - Madeleine's Fund: Leaving no Stone Unturned Limited, up to 3 December 2011


Recent screenshot advertising Kate McCann's book in audio format, paypal button and the online merchandising store, taken on 12 December 2011

*work in progress, contributions are welcomed, thanks to McCannFiles and GerryMcCann's Blogs for keeping all the material on the McCann case archived, thanks also to those that are helping this compilation.


Gonçalo Amaral: “Justice works in Silence”

11 December 2011 | Posted by  34 comments

“Justice works in Silence”

His life has been ripped apart since he led the police investigation into the Millennium’s greatest mystery, and came into legal confrontation with Kate and Gerry McCann. Gonçalo Amaral has lost his family, his business, his assets and the income from his controversial book that states all the reasons why he believes three-year-old Madeleine McCann died in apartment 5A in Praia da Luz back in May of 2007. Now, four-and-a-half years down the line, he faces another hurdle: a trial for defamation of the McCanns – due to start in Lisbon in February – in which the couple are claiming 1.2 million euros in damages. Does he think he can win? “Of course”, he says. This is the man whose maxim is “justice works in silence”. He still believes the case of the world’s most famous missing person will be solved. And he told Algarve123 what he thinks is needed to get there…
You wouldn’t miss him in a crowd. Gonçalo Amaral, 52, is strikingly tall with a penchant for hats. He was wearing a long black coat, a black fedora and a bright red scarf when we met him on the terrace of Casa Inglesa in Portimão. He looked much more like an intellectual than a former police officer, but these days his life is spent largely writing - an activity he’s come to love as much as the police work that used to fill his days.

Our first question: “How’s life?” elicited the reply “Bad!” so any further niceties went by the board.

What Amaral has always maintained is that the McCanns’ zeal for litigation “will not bring their daughter back”. He claims various legal suits against him, and a number of other Portuguese public figures who have verbalised “anti-McCann-story” sentiments, are totally out of keeping with the Catholic faith so fervently embraced by Madeleine’s mother Kate.

“Is it Catholic to hold sentiments of vengeance? To seek to destroy a family as mine has been destroyed?” he asks.

“This litigation will carry a heavy price – but I have faith that the mystery will be resolved. “Even if I “disappear” in the process - as Kate McCann has written that she wishes I would in her book - I have a daughter and lots of friends who will make sure justice is done”.

It may sound theatrical - but Amaral is not about theatre. He is about truth – hard facts, solid investigative work.

“The case has to be re-opened, and I have faith that it will be,” he said. “It will either be when this current “procurador” leaves, or when the current chief of police leaves. It’s not something I am pushing for - even if I could - it’s just something I feel certain will happen. And when it does, the first, most essential thing to be done will be a reconstruction of that very first night – the night Madeleine disappeared. Because that’s what happened: she literally disappeared! The reconstruction will have to involve all the parties: the McCanns and their friends. You see, there are so many inconsistencies in these people’s statements that a reconstruction will very quickly highlight where they have not told the truth”.

An example of the power of reconstructions came only weeks ago in Spain where a father claimed his two children were abducted from a park. A police reconstruction quickly proved that the father had never taken his children to the park: witnesses who had seen him arrive in his car but hadn’t noticed the children in the back seat, were surprised to discover that in the reconstruction the child-sized dummies in the back were clearly visible. The children’s father is now in jail – although the children are still missing.

Amaral explained that when Madeleine disappeared police didn’t organise a reconstruction in Praia da Luz “because there were so many journalists on the ground” – and once the heat had died down, “the McCanns refused. They said any reconstruction should be made by actors – but the whole reason for reconstructions is to use the people involved, and see where their stories don’t add up!”

Going back to that first night is logical: the initial 48-hours after any disappearance are crucial. They can literally mean the difference between life and death – but in Madeleine’s case, Amaral is convinced of the latter. The theory that has led to his prosecution by the McCanns for defamation is clearly set out in his book “A Verdade de Mentira” (The Truth of the Lie) – banned from sale in 2009, and then “released” by the Appeals Court a year later. We say “released” because the books were actually never returned to publishers Guerra & Paz, and thus they and Amaral have had nothing to sell…

“It’s another part of the whole plot to assassinate my civil position,” Amaral says matter-of-factly. “I’ve been left with no chances; no way of paying my debts; liens on my property. I’ve had to move away from my family in order to protect them. My marriage, well, it’s not so good. Not good at all, really. My life seems to be all about divorce…”

So how does he find the strength to move forwards?

“Well, I put the McCanns in a metaphorical box and I am not really thinking too much about the trial in February. I think I will win, and then they will appeal – but I have to have a path. I want to open another consultancy. I had one when I left the police force, but that was destroyed when the McCanns went after me over “A Verdade de Mentira”.

So that’s one thing - and the other is writing. I have recently brought out a new book: “Vidas sem Defesa” about missing children cases in Portugal, and I have another one almost ready (I am not going to tell you what it is about!). After that, I would like to take police “mysteries” and study them and write stories, not novels; stories based on facts to show what I believe really happened. There’s a real lack of books of this type.”

So he’s not angry over the agonies and frustrations he’s endured from what came from essentially doing his job?

“I have my anger well-guarded. No feelings for revenge. Like I say, they will pay for what they have done to me and my family – but through the courts. Even after everything that has happened, I still have faith in the Portuguese justice system”.

And does he have any clues as to what catapulted the Madeleine case into the stratosphere of media attention? Why did the McCanns receive so much help from the British authorities right from the very beginning? And why were they and the so-called Tapas 7 never taken to task for child neglect – considering that they all left their children alone at night during the ill-fated holiday?

“Ah, now there we’re getting into politics – and quite honestly, those are questions for the British public to ask. I don’t have to have theories about them. My job was to find Madeleine”.

A job handed to him nearly five years ago – and one that he will never forget.


in Algarve123, Edition 707 (8 Dec 2011)

Maddie: Attorney General's Office not part of new investigations

6 December 2011 | Posted by  47 comments


by: Paula Oliveira

The English police is investigating the disappearance of Maddie McCann without the assistance of Portuguese authorities. This information has been confirmed to TVI24 by the [Portuguese] Republic's Attorney General.

Three Scotland Yard investigators were in Barcelona between the 23rd and the 25th of November, following leads in the disappearance of the English child that disappeared from an apartment in Praia da Luz, in the Algarve, in 2007. The presence of investigators in Spain may indicate that the child was taken across the border. But the Scotland Yard did not contact the Portuguese investigators.

«The Scotland Yard did not have any contact with the Attorney General's Office about that issue. In the process, there is no knowledge of the existence of any new data/facts about Maddie's disappearance. The process will only be reopened under the regulations of article 279 of the Penal Process Code, which is to say, if any new elements appear that invalidate the basis for the archiving», the Attorney General's Office states in a written reply to TVI24.

The case was archived by the Attorney General's Office. Approximately one year ago, Pinto Monteiro [the Attorney General] asserted that he would only reopen it if new data appeared.

In May last year, the Scotland Yard reopened the process after the personal intervention of the United Kingdom's prime minister, David Cameron.

It is not known whether the British investigators have discovered any new fact that the Portuguese police failed to notice.

In August this year, the Scotland Yard confirmed to [Portuguese news] agency Lusa that they travelled to Portugal in order to discuss the Maddie case with Portuguese investigators. At that time, the Judiciary Police (PJ) and the Attorney General said they did not know about that information.

in: TVI24, 06.12.2011